• Home
  • Subscribe
    • Individual Membership
    • ECE Service Membership (Single Licence)
    • ECE Service Membership (2 Services)
    • ECE Service Membership (3 Services)
    • Institutional or ECE Group Membership
  • About Us
  • Caring/Teaching
    • ***Articles Below For Members Only***
    • Assessment of Learning and Development
    • Book Reviews
    • Celebrating Important Occasions & Events
    • Child Abuse, Poverty, Vulnerable Children
    • Children's Behaviour and Social Skills
    • Coping with Disruptions and Transitions
    • Curriculum and Teaching (What/How/Why)
    • Gifted Young Children
    • Healthy & Safe Babies and Children
    • Health, Learning & Disability Needs
    • How-To Articles: Ideas and Activities
    • Parent Information
    • Teacher Guidance and Advice
  • Research
    • ***Articles Below For Members Only***
    • Member Discounts, Codes & Free Gifts
    • NZ Research in ECE Journal (NZRECE)
      • Volume 15 Journal Articles
      • Volume 14 Journal Articles
      • Volume 13 Journal Articles
      • Volume 12 Journal Articles
      • Volume 11 Journal Articles
      • Volume 10 Journal Articles
      • Volume 9 Journal Articles
      • Volume 8 Journal Articles
      • Volume 7 Journal Artilces
      • Volume 6 Journal Articles
      • Volume 5 Journal Articles
      • Volume 4 Journal Articles
      • Volume 3 Journal Articles
      • Volume 2 Journal Articles
      • Volume 1 Journal Articles
    • Effects of Childcare/ECE on Children
    • Research on Training, Gender & Teaching
    • Presentations at NZ Research Conference
    • Doing Research, Ethics & Publishing
    • Bios of Inspiring People & Career Options
    • Thesis List: Ph.D.s & Masters Theses
    • Discussion Board on Research Matters
    • Help Area for Researchers
  • Policy
    • ***Articles Below For Members Only***
    • Funding Policies, Practice and Evidence
    • Funding System Change Ideas
    • International Perspectives & Policies
    • International ECE News Headlines
    • Māori Cultural and Language Issues
    • Parenting & Parent Engagement in ECE
    • Political Party Policies and Views
    • Sector Concerns, Problems & Challenges
    • Surveys of the ECE Sector & Family Data
  • Men in ECE
    • Campaign for Men in ECE Blog
    • International Research & Policy Papers
    • NZ Research & Policy Papers
    • Scholarships and Invitation Grants
    • Your Questions & Answers
  • Quality
    • ABCs of Quality Childcare & Education
    • From Children's, Parents', Staff Viewpoints
    • Checklists & Rating Scales for Quality ECE
    • Research & Theory on Quality
  • Managers
    • ***Articles Below For Members Only***
    • Advertising, Communication & Networking
    • Committees, Owners, Boards, Governance
    • Employment, Staffing & Wages Guides
    • Financial Recording and Audit Preparation Guides
    • Financial Money Matters and Admin
    • Health, Safety & Technology Management
    • Parent Expectations & Involvement
    • Planning & Developing Your EC Service
    • Policy Tips, Templates, Records, Forms
    • Professional Development
    • Self-Review & Leadership for Quality
    • Starting a Centre or Home-based Service
Find out more about us and the extra help, advice and information available by clicking on the ABOUT US button above Blogs
Member Login





Forgot your password?
Forgot your username?
Not a member yet? Join ChildForum!

Quick Links
  • Contact
  • Membership / Join Us
  • Store / Online Shop
  • Weekly Alert Newsletter
  • Events
  • News Stories & Analysis
  • Blogs
  • Resources
  • Conference Reports
  • Conference Calendar
  • Parent Information
  • Childcare/ECE Options
  • Articles on ECE Services
  • Making a Complaint
  • Fees, Childcare Subsidy & Funding Rates
  • Research Snippets
  • ECE Jargon Dictionary
  • Feedback Testimonials
  • Training for Early Childhood Teaching
Supplier Links
  • Noise Monitors
  • Legal Compliance Guides & Training
  • Profile Books Online
  • Books, Puppets, etc.
  • Parent Edn Resources
  • Child Safety Resources
  • Fast Loans/ECE Finance
  • Economic Commentary
  • Web Design & Updating
Kia ora and a warm welcome to our website Blogs Studies Continue to Show that it's Not Participation in Quality Early Childhood Education or Childcare that Matters for Child Achievement but a Child's Family and Home Background

Studies Continue to Show that it's Not Participation in Quality Early Childhood Education or Childcare that Matters for Child Achievement but a Child's Family and Home Background

Thursday, 02 August 2012 12:00 | Written by ChildForum http://www.childforum.com | PDF | Print | E-mail

New findings coming out of the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children reportedly show that childcare does not negatively affect the development of 2 and 3 year old children.  A significant difference between the groups was apparent on only one of nine measures - boys who had been in a combination of centre-based and home care as babies tended to have more conflicts with childcare teachers.

A second study, by Rebekah Levine Coley, a professor of developmental and educational psychology at Boston College, based on the Australian data,  also found no detrimental effects from infant childcare. Children performed better at school if they had been in childcare at ages two and four. But behaviour problems among the four-year-olds were worse than among four-year-old cared for at home.

A third study found four-year-olds who went to a pre-school or an educational early childhood programme had an initial significant cognitive advantage when they started school. But by age eight or nine, the academic skill advantage had disappeared.

''The biggest influence on children's academic achievement and behaviour remains family background rather than childcare,'' says Dr Harrison, lead researcher with the Longitudinal study and associate professor of early childhood at Charles Sturt University.

To read more about this click here.

Also see a summary of the best evidence on the effects of participation in ECE on children, click here. 

Please add your comments and thoughts to this blog.

Tags:
  • academic
  • achievement
  • background
  • childcare
  • effects
  • family
  • home
  • outcomes

Comments 

 
+2 # Frances Dearnley 2012-08-03 14:16
Interesting that the main indicator of difference was the home life of the children studied. We need more focus on supporting parents of young children in their role, rather than pushing parents (especially single parents) out to outside employment as early as possible. If all policies had the child at the centre of the decisions then the outcomes might be better!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
Refresh comments list

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Send
Cancel
 
DO YOU LOVE THIS PAGE? PLEASE SHARE THE LOVE!

Related Articles

  • What the Research Says about ECE Effects and the Influence of Parents/Families on Development and Educational Outcomes (1 match)
    • outcomes
  • Vaccinations Provided En-Masse at Christchurch Daycare (1 match)
    • effects
  • Shakespeare and Superheroes: Boys and Underachievement (2 matches)
    • achievement
    • outcomes
  • Parents as First Teachers: A Descriptive Study of the NZ PAFT Programme (1 match)
    • outcomes
  • Being Informed - 21 November 2011 (1 match)
    • childcare
Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyReturns & Refunds PolicySitemap
Copyright © 2010 Childforum
Site by ActionOnline