Office of Pre-Primary Education and Childcare


Follow us on FacebookFollow us on Twitteryoutube

Member Login

Member and Library Subscriber Article Drop-down Menus


Problem with Education Official's Reassurance to ECE Service Owners

Ministry of Education head office Wellington

The Education Ministry is speaking out in public to defend private industry in early childhood education, but an official's statement may irritate the Finance Minister and leave the ECE sector wondering about its capacity to provide informed advice and analysis to Government.

In the Ministry's Early Learning Bulletin sent to every early childhood operator in the country an official wrote:

A couple of weeks back the New Zealand Herald ran a series of articles about early childhood education (ECE). Not all of what they wrote was accurate. Peter Hughes, the Secretary for Education, wrote to the Herald to provide some facts. You can read his piece here. I wanted to use this issue of He Pānui Kōhungahunga to let you know what I think about early learning in New Zealand. 
First of all, as you know, quality ECE can make a real difference to a child’s life. The New Zealand-based Competent Children, Competent Learners study found that the positive effects from ECE continued at ages 14 and 16, while economist James Heckman has found an economic rate of return of around 7-10% for government investment in ECE. The research clearly shows that children who are involved in some form of early learning do better in their later education – and in life

The Ministry appears to be relying once again on this one study for 'proof' when it was pointed out to it as far back as 2005 that it should be careful not to overgeneralise the research findings beyond that warranted by the data.  

The actual justification for government investment in ECE is an economic one. By investing in ECE Government is helping to reduce a barrier for parents to engage in paid work or study and provide jobs for a mainly female workforce by increasing the size of the early childhood education industry. 

Labour market research is therefore perhaps more relevant than American James Heckman's productivity arguments on providing early intervention programmes involving parents for disadvantaged children likely to engage in crime later in life and have poor educational outcomes as adults.  NZ ECE services are not the same as the early intervention programmes referred to and our population and social policies are different.  



For articles on the Competent Children research and the findings of other NZ, Australian and overseas studies on the effects of participation in ECE on children click here.

Free E-Newsletter

Receive the free Early Childhood Alert.


We hate spam as much as you, we will not sell your contact details to anyone.

You can unsubscribe at any time.

Read our Privacy Policy here.

Don’t miss out any longer, click the button below to join ChildForum


  • Preschool Leader

    Having heard a colleague talk about how useful she had found their material I joined. ChildForum's replies to my queries are prompt, extremely informative & with a genuine personal touch. I am impressed by the commitment to research & courage in tackling the hard issues like the risks of poor quality care for under 2s
    Val Morrison (Small is Beautiful)
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

Join Us!



Subscribe now for information you can trust, expert advice and research, as well as access to quality resources

We are confident you will be delighted to discover and experience the benefits of membership - so join now and make this message for non-members disappear from your screen. 

Membership Options


Who is this for?
Any person who has an interest in early childhood education and care or who works directly with children.

$98.00 12 months from the date of joining
$60.00 6 months student-only

The membership belongs to you, and you only. Enjoy your own personal username and password.

ECE Service Organisation

Who is this for?
Centres, home-based, hospital-based, playgroups ... established or newly licensed. Gives access to professional & research materials enjoyed by individual members PLUS service operation and management area. 

$198.00 12 months for a standalone licensed service
Special rates for organisations with more than 1 licence

The membership belongs to your whole organisation, team members and managers.

Library NZ-International Research
in ECE Journal Subscriber

Who is this for?
Universities, Polytechnics and organisations wishing to have online access to the NZ-Int Research in ECE journal (includes all past and current issues) 

$125.00 annual subscription, renewable in November each year

A username and password for your library users linked to your IP address.